If Sator's dead man's switch was meant to trigger the algorithm, then it's "end of play"to use Neil's wordsas soon as Sator got killed. The tenet universe follows a "block universe" model, a.k.a, "What's happened, happened." There is however a solution to this paradox: But how did this work for the original cache of gold Sator found in Stalsk-12? They want revenge, not just suicide. All relevant dialogue and character actions say otherwise. The rule of the tenet universe prevents it. But the algorithm (which is the fuel for the neuclear explosion) has been extracted safely, just in time, so it's not triggered. What is a temporal pincer, you ask? The location of the dead drop is significant because it allows the algorithm to be recovered and activated in the future. Kat: I couldn't do it. Alternatively, that gold bar was actually a regular bar that came out of the turnstile. Its trying a little bit. 6+ Thoughts I Had Watching When Harry Met Sally For The First Time, The Voices Niall Horan Says Meeting Blake Shelton Was Fate, Reveals How Theyre Already Hanging Out Beyond The Show. rev2023.5.1.43404. Which language's style guidelines should be used when writing code that is supposed to be called from another language? He recruited himself for the mission. Does he have a romantic relationship with her? WebThe algorithm will be created in the future by a future scientist as a way to turn back time since their future Earth is ruined by decisions made by present-day humans. But the minds behind activating the algorithm decided that it was worth the risk because they were screwed anyway. Do you know the answers to some of these questions? Are we talking stock tips? It works long enough to enjoy the movie, but at some point it breaks down. Sator Despite not knowing he constantly goes to bat for her. What positional accuracy (ie, arc seconds) is necessary to view Saturn, Uranus, beyond? Unbeknownst to him he is actually hanging out with the 'future' Kat who knows his plans and is attempting to keep him alive long enough to prevent the activation of The Algorithm. While The Protagonist is in the car, the heat from the explosion starts to freeze the windows and he blacks out as the car explodes. How did the car end up at the port after explosion in Tenet? Is it possible that people in the past actually know more about inversion than people in the future, since the past was forced to use it to wage espionage and intelligence warfare? The people in the future (posterity) are expecting Sator to send them the location of the assembled algorithm (inside the capsule / dead drop), so they could get it in the future and trigger it then. @galacticninja - that question you have linked to has no consensus on an answer. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Thats why its much easier to destroy something than to construct something. Looks like Sator's tracker then triggers a minor fuse which causes the algorithm to cause a nuclear Armageddon. Its far less grounded into physics. I guess it could be used by forward people to just as well. In the movie, reverse time has its own logic that is explained to some length. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Of course, what the movie did not depict was Sator putting everything back into the capsule (forward in time) for his inverted henchman to go bury it (the reverse of him digging it up). Why didn't the algorithm detonate when Kat killed Sator? rev2023.5.1.43404. WebThe tech has been monopolised in the future by a Russian oligarch named Andrei Sator, who has created an algorithm that allows him to invert his entropy, via turnstiles. What were the most popular text editors for MS-DOS in the 1980s? Theres a really fundamental law in physics telling us that entropy always increases. Esquire explained, The Protagonist inverted himself in the future, set up the whole mission, then went on to recruit Neil and arm him with the information he needed to help. The Protagonist throws the bag of bombs away and the people are saved. We have seen when going through a turnstile both the past inverted-self and the forward-moving-self exist simultaneously (as seen in the proving windows). Thus you have inverted and un-inverted Tenet soldiers fighting against Sators men, while The Protagonist and Ives (played by a near-unrecognisable Aaron Taylor-Johnson), both on the red team, head down into the bunker to nab the Algorithm, Empire continued. This is known as The Grandfather Paradox and is mentioned in the film. you have no life of your own left. Be Renewed For Season 6 To Hit A Major Milestone? We learn that Sator communicates with people from the future and, as a result, gets an advantage in terms of information. But this particular aspect makes sense if you model reality as an infinite boundary value problem (with "email being sent" and "algorithm being buried" as two boundary conditions to which the reality differential equation is required to conform). It's not like The Protagonist doesn't know this either, he is later chastised by Neil, but even after that they continue to work together. Does she meet up with 'past' Sator again to ensure she endures the suffering just so that it leads to the success of team Tenet? The mission: prevent Andrei Sator, a renegade Russian oligarch with precognition abilities, from starting World War III. Nolan is a known fan twist endings, non-linear story telling and generally just making his audience say "huh?". @MovieMe There is no "time and place" their world ends aside from the "sometime, somewhere" of the man the in crystalline tower. Not to get into a physics lesson, but inversion is this idea of material that has had its entropy inverted, so its running backwards through time, relative to us., Nolan consulted Nobel laureate Kip Thorne on Tenet -- Thorne also worked with the filmmaker on Interstellar -- but ended up relegating some of his suggestions. This is the man who was present for every major operation outside of the actual killing of Sator. The Los Angeles Times spoke with Claudia De Rham, a theoretical physicist from Imperial College London, and asked her if the science in the film holds up. What happened to the algorithm at the end of the movie? He uses the instructions and the gold to get a leg up on the rest of the world and ultimately become a billionaire. U4PPP Lieu dit "Rotstuden" 67320 WEYER Tl. Finally, it goes back underground when the bulldozer goes in reverse. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. He is then abducted and tortured until he bites on an apparent suicide pill before revealing any information. It requires us to imagine information Nolan didn't actually show us: What if the box that young Sator dug up came equipped with its own mini-turnstile? But just because The Protagonist spoiled the future generation's plans this time doesn't mean that they won't be back for more. He is doing all of this inverted for the first time. Zack Snyder Pushes Back On The Idea That His Superman Was Angry, And Explains His True Goal With DCs Man Of Steel, Emma Watson Gets Candid About Stepping Away From Acting After Harry Potter, Little Women: I Wasnt Very Happy, Yes, Robert Pattinsons Batmobile Designers Busted Out The Pink Paint For Barbie Immediately After Wrapping On The DC Film, Khlo Kardashian Rocked Side Butt Cutouts After Sister Kim Surprised Her With A Trip To See Usher, The Daily Show's Roy Wood Jr. Roasted 'A-Holes' Tucker Carlson And Don Lemon At The White House Correspondent Dinner, To Celebrate His Return To The UK, Steve-O Dropped A Throwback Video Partying With Naked Women, Cruel Intentions Star Joshua Jackson Has A Very Specific Complaint About Some Hollywood Sex Scenes, Matthew Lawrence Alleges Turning Down Major Hollywood Director's Sexual Advances Lost Him A Marvel Role And More, Sydney Sweeney Rocked A Sheer White Skirt With Black Lingerie As Rumors Swirl About Her Rom-Com Co-Star Glen Powell, Will Magnum P.I. But what if a random person stumbled on the gold bars. Hi Zonker, do you have any sources to back your theory up? So, now he will be able to invert himself, retrieve an inverted capsule, and then uninvert himself and the gold. New York, But even after these events, and saving Sator's life, he still fights for her. The people in the future financed and guided Sator to find and reassemble the algorithm, not to trigger or activate it. Very late to the party, but being able to rewatch Tenet numerous times on HBOMax (with subtitles!) You see the gold fall out of Sators hand since the scene is moving backwards. Is there a situation where the future can go back and make some minor tweaks to the timeline, like knocking off The Protagonist before the events of the film? What we haven't established is how he connects to the larger picture and if he may be involved with The Protagonist. We already know that The Protagonist used a fake Francisco Goya drawing to meet with Kat and ultimately get close to her husband, Sator. The link doesn't help give closure to people who are reading this thread. Andrei Sator (Kenneth Branagh)'s goal in the film is to bring together nine pieces of the Algorithm an invention from the future that, when activated, will 'reverse The film never gives us a chance to see their emotional feelings for each other. In reverse, he puts it into the capsule, and it goes off to the turnstile. Since the future has access to all of Sator's records at once (ex: Sator typing a message, waiting five days, and then typing another isn't going to affect which one the future sees first - they'll all just show up at once), then how do they actually communicate at all? He ultimately fails, crashes the car and Sator commends him for his efforts, noting that he got his heart rate all the way up to 130, which has never happened before. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Kat: Worst thing Andrei ever did to me was that offer he made me. Kat failed to prevent Sator from dying (and actually caused his death herself), but the algorithm didn't trigger or activate. I'm going to see the film a second time in a few days. I mean, their outlook is pretty hopeless after all. Try thinking of the journey of the gold bar from its perspective, and it will start making sense that why this is not a paradox. Sator even uses her as an emotional and physical hostage against The Protagonist. There is some element of physics. In fact the movie even tells us that Tenet wasn't founded in the past, it's founded in the future, presumably by The Protagonist after the events of the film. Conseils The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? | On average, things get more and more disorganized. In the future, they have the ability to greatly miniaturize their turnstile technology to fit within the time capsule, and besides, this is their smaller model, only needed to be big enough to accommodate the initial gold bar shipment. Theres also additional information about possible environmental damage and the Earth becoming uninhabitable in the future, but the film doesnt dwell on that too much. This may seem like another high class art dealer with a fancy name, but Arepo is actually connected to the film via the Sator Square, a famous latin palindrome. The main goal of the people in the future is not to destroy the world. You can't know what that means to a mother. Sator did not refer to himself or his present when talking about who will trigger or when armageddon (the algorithm) is triggered. @galacticninja Hmm fare point. Starring John David Washington, Robert Pattinson, Elizabeth Debicki, Dimple Kapadia, Michael Caine, Kenneth Branagh and others, Tenet is Nolans take on an old-school spy thriller, with his own science-fiction spin. Shortly after saving Kat, the Protagonist is kidnapped and taken to a warehouse that has a Turnstile inside of it. Kat preventing Sator from killing himself is just the "backstop" and not the main part of the operation. Adrei Sator rose to power because he discovered correspondence from the future alongside a hefty stash of gold. How does time in Tenet work? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. He also, it would appear recruited himself, setting up the mission which he would recruit his past self into without knowing that the version of him the future is the one pulling all of the strings., His loop closed, Neil tells The Protagonist, Whats happened, happened, but instead that in the future the world was always safe because they had already gone into the past to make it so., Dedicated professionals who write about cinema and television in all their vibrancy. What is this brick with a round back and a stud on the side used for? We're responsible. It ends with a revelation. Sator cannot prevent it from happening. Here's What Jay Hernandez Told Us, Viral TikTok Of Kid Adorably Singing Jack Blacks Peaches Has Me Thinking The Super Mario Bros. Song Might Be The New Let It Go, 10 Best Kellyoke Covers From The Kelly Clarkson Show, Who Should Replace Henry Cavill As Superman? Priya: We all do, don't we? Does this create paradox every time someone stumbles on some random inverted stuff? Why typically people don't use biases in attention mechanism? Priya: Sator's lifelong mission, financed and guided by the future, has been to find and reassemble the algorithm. This diagram is the best/only drawing I could find on the internet depicting the path of the inverted gold. Kat: Let me go if I agreed never to see my son again. There are a number of events that couldn't happen the way they do. After the complement, he promptly sets the car on fire and walks away from the explosion cool-guy style. Expect views, reviews and news. If total energies differ across different software, how do I decide which software to use? New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition. But in the movie you just see the capsule being dug out. Does 'future' Kat return to her timeline to live out the rest of her days happily with her son? Here's where it gets crazy. She was deeply hurt when Sator coerced her not to see Max again. Embedded hyperlinks in a thesis or research paper. But Sator couldn't have removed the original set of gold (or any other object) from it's capsule, as doing so would create a paradox? The caches that Sator retrieves are being inverted by an unknown agent in our future, and are placed in the ground while in the reverse timeflow to be uncovered in the past (our presents). I knew you'd find a way. During the operation, the plutonium is found to be fake. And yet, this is not how Tenet functions at all. Except, both sides are actually experiencing it simultaneously.. At one point in Tenet Andrei Sator, played by Kenneth Branagh, tells The Protagonist that this whole mess was started because of the future generation's desire When Kat shoots Sator, why doesn't the algorithm detonate? In fact, it would make for a pretty clever temporal pincer movement. By use of a turnstile, Neil's entropy is inverted, sending him backward to Tenet's present where he meets a younger version of The Protagonist, and sacrifices In the final scenes of Tenet it is revealed that all the good guys, even The Protagonist, were working for the 'future' version of The Protagonist all along. Updated answer. Dont get me wrong, Tenets an amazing film. Where is Sator between the Vietnam Yacht and Italy? Imagine an inverted henchman dug up the capsule and brought it immediately to the yacht. In Kiev, Ukraine, an unnamed operative, The Protagonist (John David Washington), assists in a CIA assignment to foil an opera siege and retrieve a stolen cache of plutonium. I'm starting to confuse myself again. Sator says that he is not destroying the world, but "creating a new one" (for the people in the future). Kat mentions that first drawing was sold by a dealer named Arepo. The unknown future agent knew Sator would be there to discover the buried and inverted cache. So in this way Stator leaves the original inverted gold in place to preserve its chain of causation from the future, while simultaneously having regular gold available to him to buy all the necessary components for his first home-built turnstile. She's killed him. How can the future protect themselves by wiping out the past in Tenet? An unknown agency is working with Sator to kill everyone in the past, because they're responsible. Regarding your bonus question, I like to picture the scene on the yacht played in reverse. Sator: Somewhere, sometime, a man in a crystalline tower throws a switch and armageddon is both triggered and avoided. It's hard to say because the film only explores the second Goya fake but Arepo's connection to the Sator Square seems a little too convenient for me and ultimately leads to my next question. Please take the. Instructions are to press a button on the side, and boom! If so, how was it inverted? This is completely avoided if you dig it out in reversed mode and then invert the bar, as this way there's one consistent gold timeline. A minor scale definition: am I missing something? @galacticninja your answer to that assumes that after being buried, it appears instantly in the future (it's waved off as from the future's perspective it's instantaneous). Neil: Seemingly instantaneous. The reversed car that crashed on the highway and burned, how long will the wreck lie there (or has been lying there in forward time) without anyone calling the police. Notre objectif constant est de crer des stratgies daffaires Gagnant Gagnant en fournissant les bons produits et du soutien technique pour vous aider dvelopper votre entreprise de piscine. How the heck did he know the code? According to Neil, Sator's fitness tracker is (emphasis mine): "linked to a switch, probably a simple e-mail burst that. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. First, look at this from Sator's perspective: when he digs the ground to retrieve the gold, the gold was already present in the ground in his past. Was there some tom foolery done by someone ahead of time to a combination that The Protagonist would have guessed first? Anything that goes into the record speaks directly to the future. It just sends out the location of the dead drop (the buried capsule). Win/win, right? Why didn't the machine beep when Joker killed this person? I'm going to outline ten of my biggest questions after seeing Tenet but before you read on know that This article is completely and totally filled with spoilers for TENET. James Gunn Shares What Hes Looking For, Simon Pegg, Pom Klementieff And More Reach Out As Christopher McQuarrie Gets Mission: Impossible 7 In The Can 3 Years (And Millions Of Extra Dollars) Later, Ahead Of The Equalizer's Return, Actress Lorraine Toussaint Shares What She's Proud Of After Three Seasons. The film makes it all clear that the Future has identified Sator as the man to end the world in his time. If the gold has been burried in a specific location for Sator to discover at some specific time and place, then the future of the gold after the discovery is to be burried. She killed him. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Prsentation He was a Russian oligarch used by future generations Sator is working with this future generation to find the pieces of the algorithm that are traveling back through time, reassemble them, and invert our entire world. He does not know it for sure. Pourquoi choisir une piscine en polyester ? But it works only so far. Criticism for the film seems to be focussed on two things: its complicated plot and unclear sound mixing. What would that do to the future? The "dead man's switch" (Sator's fitness tracker) is not connected to the time bomb in the hypocentre: Key term is in effect; the email has no role in activating the algorithm, it's a signal to the future that allows the reality in which the algorithm is activated to exist. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Why isn't Sator 2 (inverted Sator) wearing an oxygen mask when he goes back to his yacht in Vietnam for his final moment? Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. is there such a thing as "right to be heard"? Its future is The If you send enough of it back the man is sure to be rich but to become a billionaire is a whole other level. In any case, the gold bar will reach the ground on Dec 31st one way or the other. Presumably the two are in for some hijinks that take place in the past. What you described (inverting ourselves and then retrieve gold) is a mechanism to prevent the "supposed paradox." What I like about the diagram is that, after the empty capsule is buried, the next thing that happens is both regular gold and inverted gold suddenly come out of the turnstile much like The Protagonist and the inverted Protagonist suddenly coming out of the turnstile at the Oslo Freeport. When he dies, the fuse goes off. To get closer to Sator and keep a promise to Kat The Protagonist promises to destroy the fake Goya drawing that he holds above her head. | At the beginning of the film, an Esquire article attempts to explain, the Protagonist meets Clmence Posys scientist, who informs him that at some point in the future, a technology is invented that can reverse the entropy of people and objects. The tech has been monopolised in the future by a Russian oligarch named Andrei Sator, who has created an algorithm that allows him to invert his entropy, via turnstiles. I'm not sure, but what I am sure of is that I would totally watch John David Washington and Robert Pattinson hop through time fighting off tricks and traps sent back by the future generation. It is We learn that Sator communicates with people from the future and, as a result, gets an advantage in terms of information. When a material or person is inverted, its But the time capsule has to travel to the future at the standard rate of 1 sec/sec while buried. I understand that Kat is the only one close enough to Sator to fool him in the end but there is no possible way that The Protagonist knew she was that important at the beginning. The bomb that seals the shaft is shown, explicitly and repeatedly, to be activated by a timer. | Now that I think of it, the people from the future could have burried a complete working turnstile. My question is what else was in those little inverted time capsules, outside of gold, pieces of the Algorithm and assembly instructions? Her husband now holds the mistake above her head and uses it to leverage access to her son. The "choice" alluded to by Kat is a reflection of Sator's perception of his own agency; it is notable that he is also said to be a madman. Sator: That's exactly what they're doing. At the physical level, if you have a box and you put some gas in it, the gas will start taking up the whole space. Is it all just a last ditch effort scenario? You can figure it out by thinking of how that inverted gold bar gets to the future (not in the capsule). Many surprising events are a logic extrapolation of the consequences of time flowing in reverse. Why is it shorter than a normal address? The same sunshine we basked in will warm the faces of our descendants' generations to come. Interpreting non-statistically significant results: Do we have "no evidence" or "insufficient evidence" to reject the null? Note the words: "backstop" and "and". Scan this QR code to download the app now. Sator: I'm not, I'm creating a new one. Ralisations I couldn't let him die thinking he'd won. You're a traitor. Into tracksuits by Paulie Walnuts, the Criterion Channel and Robert Eggers. The only residue issue with this is that, even if buried, the algorithm could still be dug out and destroyed before the Future gets it, so why all the fuss at all. Tenet is the product of a different world than Interstellar. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. If so, please let me know if the comments because I'm genuinely curious. Another not-so-big surprise from Tenet and director Christopher Nolan is the amount of questions we had after catching the film on the big screen. You will notice other names and events from the film on the Sator Square, including ROTAS, OPERA and the films title Tenet. Ralisation Bexter. The fitness tracker's dead man's switch only reveals the location of the dead drop to posterity. Have a theory that explains something I missed? You may recognize Sator as the surname of Kenneth Branagh's Russian villain, Andrei Sator. Kat: A chance to help save my child. How do I stop the Flickering on Mode 13h? WebYes. The people in the future believe that reversing the entropy Could the inversion machine the protagonist came out of fit a sedan? A helpful diagram of that process is found in the link below. Why was it important to stop the Algorithm from being dropped into the time capsule? Are there any canonical examples of the Prime Directive being broken that aren't shown on screen? Opera is obviously the location of the first big action scene, and Tenet is, of course, the title. The question is: will deleting the past erase all the damage done to the earth and fix their situation in the future? Contact Sator's dead man's switch by itself will not detonate the algorithm. I agree with the eternal conflict of present vs the future, and the future has to get lucky only once, but changing perspective from present to the future doesnt make the time capsule appear in the future. Protagonist: Yeah, found a way*. That raises the question why couldn't they have just excavated the time capsule after it was buried. Is this a constant battle spanning generation over generation that The Protagonist and his team must constantly fight? He agrees to destroy the Goya just to get closer to her husband, fails, then manages to get to him anyway. At the end of Tenet Neil (Robert Pattinson), tells The Protagonist that their friendship is just beginning. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. In fact, we see that those current-day scientists are discovering random inverted stuff all over the place. Neil then mentions that The Protagonist may be the first person in history to get hypothermia from an explosion. To understand Sator and the descendants, one needs to first understand Tenet's unique method of time travel: inversion. How did it get there in forward time? Sator's tracker is connected to this fuse. When a gnoll vampire assumes its hyena form, do its HP change? After their initial meeting Kat confronts The Protagonist about the obvious forgery and says that she's been fooled once before, coincidentally by another fake Goya drawing. Sator is okay with this because he has a terminal disease and doesnt want the world to live on after him. You jumped the gun! Passing negative parameters to a wolframscript, "Signpost" puzzle from Tatham's collection. I did have Kip Thorne read the script and he helped me out with some of the concepts, though were not going to make any case for this being scientifically accurate, Nolan said in the films press notes.

Emi Records Demo Submission, How To Write A Witness Statement For A Friend, Pastorless Baptist Churches, Articles T